- Posts: 2522
× Members
DWP QUERYING TRIBUNALS DECISION!
- JANICE
- Topic Author
13 years 7 months ago #54746 by JANICE
DWP QUERYING TRIBUNALS DECISION! was created by JANICE
Hi there
a bit confused about what has happened now, so thought I would see if this has happened to anyone else. Won my Tribunal on 22/03/2011 (both claims) and phoned DWP to ask when amending payments (Tribunal put me in Work Support Group) and arrears would be made. First time I rang they said they had not got copies of decisions which I duly photocopied and sent to them. Rang then again today and they said they needed information from Tribunal services as to how they arrived at their decisions as my points had gone from 0 to 18 and 6 to 24). I was a bit surprised as I thought DWP had to comply with a Tribunals Decision.The person I spoke to at DWP also said that if they disagreed with information supplied by Tribunal I might have to have another medical!Is this normal procedure or am I just being fobbed off?! If I could afford to I would just walk away from this the level of stress you have to put up with is ridiculous! Any advice please. Thanks JANICE
a bit confused about what has happened now, so thought I would see if this has happened to anyone else. Won my Tribunal on 22/03/2011 (both claims) and phoned DWP to ask when amending payments (Tribunal put me in Work Support Group) and arrears would be made. First time I rang they said they had not got copies of decisions which I duly photocopied and sent to them. Rang then again today and they said they needed information from Tribunal services as to how they arrived at their decisions as my points had gone from 0 to 18 and 6 to 24). I was a bit surprised as I thought DWP had to comply with a Tribunals Decision.The person I spoke to at DWP also said that if they disagreed with information supplied by Tribunal I might have to have another medical!Is this normal procedure or am I just being fobbed off?! If I could afford to I would just walk away from this the level of stress you have to put up with is ridiculous! Any advice please. Thanks JANICE
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- cdcdi1911
- Offline
Less More
13 years 7 months ago #54753 by cdcdi1911
Replied by cdcdi1911 on topic Re: DWP QUERYING TRIBUNALS DECISION!
Hi Janice
Both appellants and the DWP have a right to apply for a Statement of Reasons for the decision and appeal to the Upper Tribunal if they disagree with the reasoning. It's quite rare for the DWP to do this but it's possible that they are considering it.
Good luck
Derek
Both appellants and the DWP have a right to apply for a Statement of Reasons for the decision and appeal to the Upper Tribunal if they disagree with the reasoning. It's quite rare for the DWP to do this but it's possible that they are considering it.
Good luck
Derek
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- JANICE
- Topic Author
13 years 7 months ago #55079 by JANICE
Replied by JANICE on topic Re: DWP QUERYING TRIBUNALS DECISION!
Hi Derek
thank you for the info. Have now had a letter from DWP stating that they will not apply the tribunals decision to my claim yet. They have requested a copy of the Tribunals full statement of Reasons and when they receive it they will let me know their decision!Maybe because I went from 0 to 18 and 6 to 24 (points) they need to see how the scores have been awarded, but I dont see the point in attending a Tribunal with all the stress it involves if DWP can choose to ignore their findings.Also despite mentioning hearing problems at both medicals and at the Tribunal and having recently been diagnosed with significant hearing loss in both ears(waiting for hearing aids for both ears now), I received no score on the hearing bit of the medical!Sorry I am just having a bit of a rant, I guess I thought everything was sorted but it would seem not! Thanks for listening . JANICE
thank you for the info. Have now had a letter from DWP stating that they will not apply the tribunals decision to my claim yet. They have requested a copy of the Tribunals full statement of Reasons and when they receive it they will let me know their decision!Maybe because I went from 0 to 18 and 6 to 24 (points) they need to see how the scores have been awarded, but I dont see the point in attending a Tribunal with all the stress it involves if DWP can choose to ignore their findings.Also despite mentioning hearing problems at both medicals and at the Tribunal and having recently been diagnosed with significant hearing loss in both ears(waiting for hearing aids for both ears now), I received no score on the hearing bit of the medical!Sorry I am just having a bit of a rant, I guess I thought everything was sorted but it would seem not! Thanks for listening . JANICE
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- sunnybank
- Offline
Less More
- Posts: 583
13 years 7 months ago #55081 by sunnybank
Replied by sunnybank on topic Re: DWP QUERYING TRIBUNALS DECISION!
Janice
They will just wear us down until we get to the stage where we say..Enough I can't take any more and they will get what they want.
Us off the benefits.
One way or another they will win.
They will just wear us down until we get to the stage where we say..Enough I can't take any more and they will get what they want.
Us off the benefits.
One way or another they will win.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Gordon
- Offline
Less More
- Posts: 51290
13 years 7 months ago #55082 by Gordon
Nothing on this board constitutes legal advice - always consult a professional about specific problems
Replied by Gordon on topic Re:DWP QUERYING TRIBUNALS DECISION!
Janice
The DWP cannot ignore a Tribunal decision, however, they can appeal against it, in exactly the same way as you can.
That said, appeals against a Lower Tribunal decision are rare, and requesting a Statement of Reason does not mean that they will appeal.
I am afraid it is more delay, but not necessarily anything you should worry about.
Gordon
The DWP cannot ignore a Tribunal decision, however, they can appeal against it, in exactly the same way as you can.
That said, appeals against a Lower Tribunal decision are rare, and requesting a Statement of Reason does not mean that they will appeal.
I am afraid it is more delay, but not necessarily anything you should worry about.
Gordon
Nothing on this board constitutes legal advice - always consult a professional about specific problems
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- cdcdi1911
- Offline
Less More
- Posts: 2522
13 years 7 months ago #55086 by cdcdi1911
Replied by cdcdi1911 on topic Re:DWP QUERYING TRIBUNALS DECISION!
When an appeal is disallowed at the First-Tier Tribunal and the appellant appeals to the Upper Tribunal, the DWP are quite happy to enforce the FtT's decision immediately. Strangely enough, they're not so happy to do it when they are appealing.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Moderators: Gordon, Gary, BIS, Catherine, Wendy, Kelly, greekqueen, peter, Katherine, Super User, Chris, David